Smith And Wesson 686 Plus 2.5 Inch Review
Let me set the scene for you: It’s a quiet Saturday morning, the kind where you’re supposed to be sipping coffee and not thinking about how your car keys might one day save your life. Instead, you’re standing in a gun store, squinting at a wall of revolvers like they’re the most interesting thing since the invention of the microwave. That’s when the sales guy points to a sleek, matte-black thing and says, “This here’s the Smith & Wesson 686 Plus—2.5-inch barrel, and it’s got more personality than your ex’s last text.”
Okay, fine, maybe I’m exaggerating a little. But let’s be real—if you’re here, you’re probably not just browsing for fun. Maybe you’re a hunter looking for something reliable, a concealed carry enthusiast who wants a little extra reach, or just someone who likes the idea of a revolver that doesn’t look like it belongs in a Western movie (though, let’s be honest, it totally does). The 686 Plus is one of those guns that feels like it’s been sitting in the corner of a gun store for decades, but also like it just dropped in from the future because it’s that good.
First things first: the 686 Plus is a stubby, compact revolver with a 2.5-inch barrel, which means it’s not exactly a “shoot the bad guy from across the room” kind of gun. But if you’re looking for something that fits in a small holster, doesn’t weigh a ton, and still packs a punch, this is your guy. It’s based on the classic 686, which has been around since the ‘80s, but the “Plus” version is where things get interesting.
Must Read
Why the 2.5-Inch Barrel?
Now, you might be thinking, “Why not just get a longer barrel?” Fair question. Longer barrels mean more velocity, more accuracy, and generally more fun. But if you’re carrying concealed, you don’t want a gun that’s longer than your forearm. The 2.5-inch barrel is a happy medium—it’s short enough to tuck away, but long enough to give you a decent shot profile. It’s like getting a car that’s fast but also fits in your garage.
One thing to note: the 2.5-inch barrel isn’t going to win any speed contests. You’re not going to be shooting groups tighter than a drum at 25 yards, but for concealed carry or home defense, it’s more than capable. And let’s be honest, if you’re relying on your gun to stop a threat, you probably won’t be standing 25 yards away anyway.
Grip and Comfort
Here’s where the 686 Plus really shines. The grip is ergonomic, with a textured finish that doesn’t slip even when your hands are sweaty (which, let’s face it, they will be if you’re actually using the gun). It’s not the biggest grip you’ll ever hold, but it’s not so small that it feels like you’re squeezing a stress ball. It’s just right—like a well-fitting pair of jeans.

I’ve held a few revolvers in my life, and some of them feel like they’re trying to escape. The 686 Plus? It feels like it’s made for your hands. The checkered grip frame adds a little extra texture, and the overall weight is balanced just right. You won’t be doing any serious target shooting with this thing, but for daily carry, it’s comfortable enough that you won’t mind pulling it out every now and then.
Trigger Pull and Shooting Experience
Now, let’s talk about the trigger. If you’ve ever shot a revolver before, you know that trigger pulls can range from light and smooth to heavy and jerky. The 686 Plus falls somewhere in the middle—it’s not the lightest trigger you’ll ever feel, but it’s not so heavy that you’ll be exhausted after a few shots. It’s consistent, which is what matters most.
One thing that stood out to me was how smooth the break was. There’s no real “overtravel” (that annoying extra movement after the hammer falls), which means you can reset the hammer faster. That’s good news if you’re in a situation where you need to shoot multiple times. It’s not a competition-level trigger, but for self-defense or plinking, it’s more than adequate.
Reliability and Stopping Power
Let’s get real for a second: if you’re carrying a gun, you want it to work when it matters. The 686 Plus is built on the Smith & Wesson 686, which is known for its reliability. It’s a double-action/single-action (DA/SA) revolver, which means you can fire it with one hand if needed. That’s a big deal if you’re reaching for your gun in a stressful situation.

As for stopping power, this isn’t a high-velocity gun, but it’s not weak either. With the right ammo, it’ll do the job. If you’re shooting .38 Special or .357 Magnum, you’ve got options. The 2.5-inch barrel won’t give you the same terminal performance as a longer gun, but it’s still more than capable of stopping an intruder or a threat.
Who Is This Gun For?
So, who should actually buy this thing? If you’re looking for a compact, reliable revolver for concealed carry, the 686 Plus is a solid choice. It’s not the most exciting gun in the world, but it’s practical, and that’s what matters most. If you’re a hunter, it might not be your first pick, but it’s still a decent option for close-range shots.
If you’re someone who likes to geek out over specs, you might find this gun a little boring. But if you just want something that works, doesn’t break the bank, and fits in your holster, the 686 Plus is a great pick. It’s not going to win any awards, but it’s the kind of gun that just gets the job done.
Final thought: if you’re standing in a gun store, staring at this thing, and the sales guy says, “This is the one,” don’t roll your eyes. Maybe he’s right. The Smith & Wesson 686 Plus isn’t flashy, but it’s reliable, comfortable, and capable. And in the end, that’s what really matters.
